Could your black kitchen spatula contain chemicals from old electronics? Scientists explain

A black plastic spatula is cheap, doesn't scratch a non-stick pan, and can last for years. But in 2024, this ordinary kitchen utensil became the subject of a study that made headlines around the world.

Researchers from the American organization Toxic-Free Future and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam discovered flame retardants in black plastic household products, including kitchen utensils. They suspected the chemicals came from recycled electronics.

So, should you still be worried about the one sitting in your kitchen drawer?

What scientists discovered inside black kitchen utensils

The 2024 study published in Chemosphere examined 203 black plastic products purchased in American stores, including 109 kitchen utensils.

Researchers found bromine levels above 50 milligrams per kilogram in 20 products. Nine were kitchen utensils. Further testing identified flame retardants in some products, including substances normally used to make electronics less flammable.

One chemical was decaBDE, also called BDE-209, a persistent flame retardant associated with environmental and health concerns.

The researchers suspected that plastic from discarded electronic equipment had entered the recycling process and eventually been used to manufacture everyday household products.

However, the study did not establish that every black plastic utensil contains these chemicals.

The calculation mistake that changed the findings

The original study estimated that using contaminated utensils could expose someone to 34,700 nanograms of BDE-209 daily.

Initially, researchers compared this figure with a reference dose of 42,000 nanograms. But that reference dose was incorrect. The actual figure was 420,000 nanograms for the assumed adult body weight.

A December 2024 correction acknowledged the mistake. Then, in July 2025, a second correction reduced the estimated daily exposure itself from 34,700 to just 7,900 nanograms. That is approximately 2% of the reference dose used in the corrected comparison.

The researchers maintained that their central finding remained valid: some black plastic household products contained flame retardants.

However, the corrections considerably weakened the original suggestion of exposure approaching a potentially concerning threshold. The actual health risk from ordinary utensil use remains uncertain.

German researchers tested 26 black spatulas

There is reassuring news for European consumers.

In January 2025, German consumer organization Stiftung Warentest published laboratory results for 26 black plastic spatulas sold in Germany. None contained detectable levels of the flame retardants investigated.

However, a separate Belgian consumer test of 17 kitchen utensils detected decaBDE in one soup ladle, at 9.4 milligrams per kilogram. The organization reported that all tested products complied with applicable European requirements.

The findings suggest that contamination is possible, but the American results cannot automatically be applied to every European kitchen.

What European and UK regulations say

In the European Union, decaBDE is restricted under legislation governing persistent organic pollutants. Food-contact materials are not covered by the recycled-material exemptions provided for certain other products.

The UK also restricts decaBDE under its own retained, now assimilated, persistent organic pollutants legislation. There is no general exemption allowing contaminated recycled electronics plastic to be used in kitchen utensils.

These rules reduce the likelihood of contaminated products reaching consumers, although they cannot guarantee that every utensil is free from unwanted chemicals.

The one cooking habit worth changing today

The concern isn't simply that a spatula is black. It is what happens when certain chemicals in plastic are exposed to heat.

To estimate exposure, the researchers drew on earlier experiments measuring how BDE-209 could migrate from plastic utensils into hot cooking oil.

That makes prolonged contact with hot fat a sensible precaution to avoid. If you regularly leave a plastic spatula resting inside a hot frying pan, consider changing that habit.

Should you throw away your black plastic spatula?

Based on the available evidence, there is no reason to empty your entire kitchen drawer.

However, a few precautions:

  • Keep utensils that are intact, suitable for food contact, and used within their stated temperature limits.
  • Be more cautious with older utensils of unknown origin or products without clear material information.
  • Never leave plastic utensils sitting in hot oil or against a hot pan for prolonged periods.
  • Replace melted, cracked, or badly worn utensils.
  • Consider wooden, stainless steel or food-grade silicone alternatives when buying replacements.

The takeaway is reassuring: the study uncovered a genuine contamination problem, but its original exposure estimates were substantially overstated.

You don't need to panic about every black spatula. Just be careful how you use it around heat.

Advertising
Adobe Stock