Grandparents put it there, and many people still do: an open box of baking soda at the back of the fridge to get rid of unpleasant smells. But according to America's Test Kitchen, this familiar household trick isn't quite as effective as we might think.
Baking soda can neutralize certain odors, but it doesn't work equally well on everything. And with holiday leftovers, strong cheeses, and other foods filling our refrigerators in the coming weeks, it could be worth knowing what works better.
Why baking soda doesn't remove every smell
Baking soda, also called sodium bicarbonate, is mildly alkaline. This means it can react with and neutralize certain acidic substances responsible for unpleasant odors.
That's why leaving an open box in the refrigerator can sometimes help. However, not every food odor comes from an acidic compound, so baking soda has its limitations.
Cleaning experts interviewed by Apartment Therapy also point out something important: baking soda cannot solve smells caused by spoiled food or bacterial growth.
If a forgotten container of leftovers is causing the problem, no amount of baking soda will make that food safe again.
What happened when researchers tested activated charcoal?
America's Test Kitchen conducted a practical comparison using two identical mini refrigerators.
One contained an open container with one cup of baking soda. The other contained one cup of activated charcoal pellets, similar to those used in aquarium filters.
Both refrigerators were exposed to strong food odors. Throughout the comparison, testers consistently judged the refrigerator containing charcoal to be significantly less smelly.
The explanation lies in charcoal's unusual structure.
Activated charcoal contains countless microscopic pores, creating an enormous surface area. Odor molecules can stick to these surfaces through a process called adsorption.
Unlike baking soda, which mainly works through chemical reactions with certain substances, activated charcoal can capture a wider variety of odor-producing compounds.
This was a practical smell comparison, not a large scientific study. Still, the results suggest charcoal may be the better choice for stubborn refrigerator odors.
How to use activated charcoal in your refrigerator
America's Test Kitchen recommends approximately two cups of activated charcoal for a full-size refrigerator.
Place it in a shallow, open container near the back of the refrigerator, preferably close to an air vent where air can circulate.
You can also use a breathable bag that keeps the pellets contained while allowing air to pass through.
Choose plain, unscented activated charcoal intended for odor control, and keep loose pellets away from uncovered food. Don't use charcoal briquettes containing lighter fluid or other additives.
Activated charcoal is available from aquarium suppliers and stores selling household odor absorbers.
It can remain effective for a month or longer, depending on how much odor it encounters. Replace it when unpleasant smells return, or follow the product's instructions.
Still prefer baking soda? Make this small adjustment
There's no need to throw away your baking soda. It can still help with everyday refrigerator smells.
However, how you place it matters.
Experts interviewed by Apartment Therapy recommend exposing as much of the powder to the air as possible.
Instead of opening just a small corner of the cardboard box, remove the entire top or pour the baking soda into a shallow bowl.
A thin layer spread across a plate provides even more exposed surface area.
The cleaning experts recommend replacing baking soda about once a month, although some product instructions suggest longer intervals.
And remember: never use baking soda that has been sitting open in your refrigerator for cooking or baking. It may have picked up unwanted odors and contaminants.
Before adding anything, check these three places
Even the best odor absorber won't fix the underlying problem if something is rotting inside your refrigerator.
Consumer Reports recommends removing the source of unpleasant smells before attempting to absorb what's left.
Start by checking the vegetable drawers, where forgotten produce can spoil. Next, inspect the door shelves for leaking containers and old condiments. Finally, look for spills beneath drawers and around the drain opening at the back.
For persistent odors, empty the refrigerator and clean its interior thoroughly. Consumer Reports also describes using baking soda or activated charcoal to absorb lingering smells, followed by wiping the interior with a mixture of equal parts plain vinegar and water.
Keep strongly scented foods in airtight containers, and make sure your refrigerator stays at 40°F (4°C) or below.
The takeaway is simple: baking soda can help, but activated charcoal may work better. Whichever you choose, removing the source of the smell is always the most important step.